1st Video
I would give this project 20 marks. The camera is not very steady at all and the shots don't flow together well. It seems that they have spent more time on the make-up than actually planning out the shots as the composition and continuity aren't great. The beginning is fuzzy and the voice-over isn't very effective. The mise-en-scene is good though, and they have used a number of shot types, although they have occasionally tried to cover them up with editing.
2nd Video
I believe this video should get around 35 marks out of 60. I don't feel it deserves a level 4 as the shots don't really flow into each other very well, making it difficult to follow the story. Also, the lighting isn't great in most of the shots. On the other hand, the camera is very steady during panning and tilting, and there are a variety of different shot types. They also have used props and costumes effectively to indicate the character is a 'tramp'.
3rd Video
I would probably give this video a level 4, but a low one, probably 45-50. I like the opening as it looks professional and has a nice effect on it. The camera work is pretty good, but occasionally the continuity is poor, e.g when the girl runs away. The mise-en-scene is good, as it is well lit and the setting is appropriate. They also have clearly put time into the costumes and make up. The composition of the camera is good as well as they have given the characters head room and lead room when running away. I think they could have included a few transitions to make the shots flow more efficiently.
4th Video
I would give this project a level 3, around 40 marks. I think the sound and editing is excellent as it really creates the right atmosphere. Furthermore, the make-up is very good and they have clearly put a lot of thought into it. The main reason I wouldn't give this a level 4 is that the lighting was poor and in some shots I couldn't tell what was happening. Also, there wasn't a great range of shot types.
Josh&Liam.